During the Soviet period, the right monarchism was considered by historians of our country as part of general methodological approaches to the study of non-proletarian parties. As ideological and political antagonist of Bolshevism, the Black Hundreds were interpreted as the most reactionary political movement of pre-revolutionary Russia. As a result, the full scienti c debate on the right monarchism in the Soviet period did not take place, and Soviet historians failed to form a historical concept of the Black Hundreds as an ideological and political trend in the early twentieth century.
Key words: Black Hundreds, the right monarchism, Soviet historical science, historiography, methodology.
References
1. Avreh A.Ja. III Duma i nachalo krizisa tret'eijun'skoj sistemy (1908–1909) [The Third Duma and the beginning of crisis for the system of 3rd June]. Istoricheskie zapiski. RAN SSSR. 1955. T. 53. pp. 50-109
2. Avreh A.Ja. Agrarnyj vopros v tret'ej Dume [Rural problems in the Third Duma]. Istoricheskie zapiski. 1958. No63. pp. 26-83
3. Avreh A.Ja. Carizm i tret'eijun'skaja sistema [Tsarism and the system of 3rd June]. Moscow: Nauka, 1966.
4. Avreh A.Ja. Carizm nakanune sverzhenija [Tsarism before being ousted]. Moscow: Nauka, 1989.
5. Bazhin A.A. Bor'ba partii bol'shevikov protiv chernosotennogo dvizhenija v gody Pervoj russkoj revoljucii (1905–1907 gg.) [Bolshevik party struggle against far-right during World War I]: PhD in History thesis. Moscow, 1979.
6. Barandov G.V. Stolypinskaja reakcija [Oppresion under Stolypin]. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izd-vo polit. lit-ry, 1938.
7. Bondarenko K.M. Russkie i belorusskie monarhisty v literature 20–30-h gg. proshlogo veka [Russian and bielorussian monarchists in literature of 1920-1930]. Białoruskie Zeszyty Historyczne, Belaruskі gіstarychny zbornіk. 2011. No35. S. 127-139
8. Volobuev P.V., Lejberov I.P. Prolog Oktjabrja. K 50-letiju Fevral'skoj burzhuazno-demokraticheskoj revoljucii [Be- fore the October. To 50th anniversary of the February bourgeois democratic revolution] .Kommunist. 1959. No 3.
9. GARF. F. 116. Op. 1. D. 23. L. 43–43ob. Doklad predsedatelja Akkermanskogo otdela Sojuza russkogo naroda k utverzhdennoj programme soveshhanij s’ezda v g. Nizhnem Novgorode 26 nojabrja 1915 g. [Report of the chairmain for Accerman division of the Union of the Russian People on the adopted agenda of the
Union’s convention, 26 November 1915]
10. GARF. F. 116. Op. 2. D. 77. L. 1ob.
11. Gorovskij F.Ja. Bor'ba bol'shevikov za razreshenie nacional'nogo voprosa v gody revoljucionnogo pod’ema
(po materialam IV Gosudarstvennoj dumy) [Bolshevik’s struggle for national problems resolution in the
years of revolutionary boost]. Moscow, 1950.
12. Gosudarstvennaja duma. Stenogra cheskie otchety. Sozyvy pervyj – chetvertyj [State Duma. Full texts of
speeches. 1-4 tenure]. Sanct-Petersberg, 1906–1917.
13. Demin V.T. Social-demokraticheskaja frakcija bol'shevikov v IV Gosudarstvennoj dume (1912–1914 gg.)
[Social-democratic bolshevik faction in the 4th Duma] . Moscow, 1947.
14. Djakin V.S. Burzhuazija, dvorjanstvo i carizm v 1911–1914 godah: razlozhenie tret'eijun'skoj sistemy [the
bourgeoisie, the nobility and tsarism in 1911-1914: decline of the system of 3rd June]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1988.
15. Djakin V.S. Samoderzhavie: burzhuazija i dvorjanstvo [The absolute monarchy: the bourgeoisie and the
nobility]. Leningrad, 1978.
16. Zavadskaja L.V. Agrarnyj vopros v I Gosudarstvennoj dume i bor'ba bol'shevikov za krest'janstvo [The rural
problems in the 1st Duma and the bolshevik struggle for the peasantry]. Bol'sheviki vo glave Pervoj russkoj
revoljucii 1905–1907 godov. Ed. by F. D. Kretova (gl. red.) [i dr.]. Moscow, 1956. pp. 431-438
17. Zaslavskij D.O. Rycar' monarhii Shul'gin [The Monarchial Knight Shulgin]. Moscow: Priboj, 1927.
18. Zevelev A.I., Sviridenko Ju.P., Pavlov D.B., Stepanskij A.D. Teoretiko-metodologicheskie, istoriogra cheskie i
arheogra cheskie aspekty [Theoretical and methodological, historiographical and archeographic aspects].
Politicheskie partii Rossii: istorija i sovremennost'. M.: ROSSPJeN, 2000. pp. 5-66
19. Zelenov M.V. Spechran i istoricheskaja nauka v Sovetskoj Rossii v 1920–1930-e gody [Special savings and
historical science in Soviet Russia in 1920-1930]. Otechestvennaja istorija. 2000. No 2. pp. 129-141
20. Ivanova A.I. Iz opyta bor'by kazanskih bol'shevikov protiv ideologii chernosotenstva v revoljucii 1905–1907 gg. [Kazan’s bolsheviks’ experience in ghting against far-right ideology in 1905-1907]. Obshhestvennye otnoshenija razvitogo socializma: (Vopr. teorii i istorii stanovlenija i sovershenstvovanija) / [Redkol.: Shhelku-
nov M. D. (otv. red.) i dr.). Kazan': Izd-vo Kazan. un-ta, 1985.
21. Io e G.3. Krah rossijskoj monarhicheskoj kontrrevoljucii [The collapse of Russian monarchic counter-rev-
olution]. Moscow, 1977.
22. Istorija Vsesojuznoj kommunisticheskoj partii (bol'shevikov). Kratkij kurs [History of All-Russian Comminist
Party (bolsheviks). The short course]. pod red. komissii CK VKP(b). Moscow: Pravda, 1938.
23. Kandidov B.P. Krestom i nagajkoj: Pochaevskaja lavra i chernosotennoe dvizhenie [Pochaivskaya Lawra and
far-right movement]. Moscow, 1928.
24. Kandidov B.P. Cerkov' v 1905 godu (ocherki i materialy) [The church in 1905]. Moscow, 1930.
25. Karpuhin D.V. Otechestvennaja istoriogra ja chernosotennyh sojuzov i organizacij [Russian historiography
of far-right unions and organizations]. PhD in History thesis. Moscow, 2008.
26. Kir'janov Ju.I. Pravye partii v Rossii. 1911–1917 gg. [Right parties in Russia. 1911-1917]. Moscow, 2001.
27. Kiselev I.N., Korelin A.P., Shelohaev V.V. Politicheskie partii v Rossii v 1905–1907 godah: chislennost', sostav,
razmeshhenie [Political parties in Russia in 1905-1907: numbers, structure, location]. Istorija SSSR. 1990.
No 4. pp. 71-87
28. Kicheev V.G. Istoriogra ja chernosotenno-monarhicheskih organizacij v Rossii v nachale XX veka [Histori-
ography of far-right organizations in Russia at the beginning of XX century]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarst-
vennogo universiteta. 2008. No 315. pp. 88-95
29. Kicheev V.G. Sovetskaja istoriogra ja chernosotenno-monarhicheskih organizacij v Rossii v nachale XX
veka [Soviet historiography of far-right organizations in Russia at the beginning of XX century]. Irkutskij istoriko-jekonomicheskij ezhegodnik. Irkutsk: Izd-vo BGUJeP, 2007. pp. 33-40
30. Koval'chuk M.A. Bol'sheviki v tret'ej Gosudarstvennoj dume [Bolsheviks in the 3rd Duma]. Leningrad, 1950.
31. Kogan I. Karatel'nye jekspedicii [Punishing operations]. Moscow, 1925.
32. Komin V.V. Bankrotstvo burzhuaznyh partij v Rossii v period podgotovki i pobedy Velikoj Oktjabr'skoj
socialisticheskoj revoljucii [Bankruptcy of bourgeois parties in Russia during the period before the Great
October socialist Revolution]. Moscow, 1965.
33. Komin V.V. Istorija pomeshhich'ih, burzhuaznyh i melkoburzhuaznyh politicheskih partij v Rossii. Fakul'tativnyj
kurs lekcij dlja studentov istoricheskogo fakul'teta pedagogicheskogo instituta. Ch. I (1900 – ijun' 1917 gg.) [The history of nobleman, bourgeois and little- bourgeois political parties in Russia. Additional course. Part I]. Kalinin, 1970.
34. Koroleva N.G. Pomeshhich'e-monarhicheskie organizacii v 1905–1907 godah [Landowners’and monarchist organizations in 1905-1907]. Obrazovanie, struktura, taktika. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v treh revoljucijah / Ed. by K.V. Gusev. Moscow: Nauka, 1989. pp. 101-104
35. Kostomarov G.D. Chernaja sotnja pod agom religii [Far-right allies with religion]. Moscow, 1931.
36. Krizis samoderzhavija v Rossii [The crisis of autocrat monarchy in Russia]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1984.
37. Lenin V.I. Stolypin i revoljucija [Stolypin and the revolution]. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. Izd. pjatoe. T. 20.
Moscow: Izd-vo polit. lit-ry, 1973. pp. 324-333
38. Lukojanov I.V. Djakin kak istorik [Dyakin as a historian]. Na puti k revoljucionnym potrjasenijam: iz istorii
Rossii vtoroj poloviny XIX – nachala XX veka: materialy konferencii pamjati V.S. Djakina / RAN In-t ros. ist.
SPb. l.; RAN In-t ros. ist. SPb. l. Sanct-Petersberg-Kishinev: Nestor-Historia, 2001. pp. 29-37
39. Ljubosh S.B. Russkij fashist Vladimir Purishkevich [Russian fashist Vladimir Purishkevich]. Leningrad, 1925.
40. Mazis S.M. Vopros o strahovanii rabochih v III Gosudarstvennoj dume i strahovaja kampanija 1912–1914 godov
[The issue of labour insurance in 3rd Duma and the campaign for insurance in 1912-1914]. Moscow, 1952.
41. Monarhija pered krusheniem. Bumagi Nikolaja II i drugie dokumenty [Monarchy before bapticising. Nikolay
the Second’s papers]. Moscow-Leningrad, 1927.
42. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v gody burzhuazno-demokraticheskih revoljucij i v period nazrevanija socialis-
ticheskoj revoljucii: materialy konferencii [Non-proletarian parties during bourgeois democratic revolutions
and preparing for the socialist revolution]. Ed by akad. I.I. Minc. Moscow, 1982.
43. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v treh revoljucijah [Non-proletarian parties under three revolutions]. Ed by K.V.
Gusev. Moscow: Nauka, 1989.
44. Neproletarskie partii Rossii. Urok istorii [Non-proletarian. Historical lessons]. Moscow: Mysl', 1984.
45. Nechkina M.V. A.S. Griboedov i dekabristy [Griboedov and the Decembrists]. Moscow: Goslitizdat, 1947.
46. Nechkina M.V. Vosstanie 14 dekabrja 1825 goda [The upprising of 14 December 1825]. Moscow: Izd-vo
AN SSSR, 1951.
47. Ol'hovskij M.Z. Vnutridumskaja dejatel'nost' bol'shevistskoj frakcii IV Gosudarstvennoj dumy [Inner-Parlia-
mentary activities of bolshevik faction in 4th Duma]. Moscow, 1952.
48. Orlov I.B. Istorik stalinskoj jepohi na «fronte istoricheskoj nauki» [Historian of the Stalinist era on the front
of historical science]. Har'kivskij istoriogra chnij zbirnik. Vip. 11. H.: HNU imeni Karazina, 2012. pp. 117-130
49. Pankratova A.M. Pervaja russkaja revoljucija 1905–1907 godov [The First Russian Revolution, 1905-1907].
Moscow: Politizdat, 1940
50. Popov F.K. Popy-chernosotency. Ivanovo-Voznesensk, 1932.
51. Rostov N.M. Duhovenstvo i russkaja kontrrevoljucija konca dinastii Romanovyh [The clergy and the Russian
counter-revolution at the end of Romanov’s era]. Moscow, 1930.
52. Russkie v XX veke [the Russians in XX century]. Moscow: OLMA Media Grupp, 2004.
53. Rylov V.Ju. Pravoe dvizhenie v Voronezhskoj gubernii (1903–1917) [Right movements in Voronezh region].
Voronezh, 2002.
54. Semennikov V.P. Monarhija pered krusheniem 1914–1917: bumagi Nikolaja II i drugie dokumenty [The
monarcy before the colapse in 1914-1917: Nikolay the Second’s papers]. Moscow-Leningrad, 1927.
55. Slepkov A.N. Klassovye protivorechija v I Gosudarstvennoj dume [The class divisions in 1st Duma]. Ed. by
M.N. Pokrovskiy. Sanct-Petersburg, 1923.
56. Sojuz russkogo naroda. Po materialam Chrezvychajnoj sledstvennoj komissii Vremennogo pravitel'stva v
1917 godu [The Union of the Russian people. Materials of the Urgent investigational commission in 1917].
sost. A. Chernovskij; red. i vstup. st. V.P. Viktorova. Moscow-Leningrad, 1929.
57. Spirin L.M. Eshhe raz o teoretiko-metodologicheskih voprosah izuchenija istorii neproletarskih partij Ros-
sii [Once again on the theoretical and methodological issues of Russian non-proletarian parties’ history]. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v gody burzhuazno-demokraticheskih revoljucij i v period nazrevanija socialis- ticheskoj revoljucii: materialy konferencii. Ed. by akad. I.I. Minc. Moscow, 1982. pp. 3-10
58. Spirin L.M. Krushenie pomeshhich'ih i burzhuaznyh partij v Rossii (nachalo XX v. – 1920 g.) [The collapse of ladowners’ and bourgeois parties in Russia]. Moscow: Mysl', 1977.
59. Stenogra cheskie otchety doprosov i pokazanij, dannyh v 1917 g. v Chrezvychajnoj sledstvennoj komissii Vremennogo pravitel'stva [Full texts o nterrogation and statements of the Urgent investigational com- mission in 1917]. T. 1–7. Moscow-Leningrad, 1924–1927.
60. Stepanov S.A. Bankrotstvo agrarnoj programmy chernosotennyh sojuzov [The bankruptcy of agrarian agenda of far-right parties]. Jakutsk: Jakut. l. Sib. otd. AN SSSR, 1981.
61. Stepanov S.A. Ideologija chernosotennyh sojuzov i organizacij [The ideology of far-right unions and orga- nizations]. Problemy istorii SSSR. M., 1982. Vyp. 12. S. 170-182
62. Stepanov S.A. Programmy chernosotennyh organizacij (1905–1907 gg.) [Programs of far-right orfanizaions in 1905-1917]. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v treh revoljucijah. Moscow, 1989. pp. 105-111
63. Stepanov S.A. Chernaja sotnja. Chto oni sdelali dlja velichija Rossii? [The Black hundred. What did the do for Russian greatness?] Moscow: Jauza-Press, 2013.
64. Stecenko A.I., Tochenyj D.S. Chernosotency Povolzh'ja v 1905 godu (k istorii bor'by social-demokratii s po- gromami pravyh monarhistov) [Far-rightist in the Volga region]. Klassovaja bor'ba v Povolzh'e v 1905–1907 godah. Kujbyshev, 1985. pp. 84-89
65. Stogov D.I. Chernosotency: zhizn' i smert' za velikuju Rossiju [The Black Hundred: life and death for the great Russia]. Ed. by O.A. Platonov. Moscow: Algoritm, 2012.
66. Sysoeva E.K. Politika ideologicheskogo vozdejstvija chernosotennyh partij na rabochih v gody Pervoj russkoj revoljucii: po materialam Moskvy i Moskovskoj gubernii: PhD in History Thesis [Far-right parties ideological policy towards proletarians during the Fisrt Russian Revolution]. Moscow, 1978.
67. Tager A.S. Carskaja Rossija i delo Bejlisa [Tsarist Russia and Bejlis’ case]. 2-e izd. Moscow, 1934.
68. Tamarkina B.M. Partija bol'shevikov v period Pervoj russkoj revoljucii [Bolshevik party during the First Rus-
sian Revolution]. Moscow, 1958.
69. Telicyn V.L. Pavel Vasil'evich Volobuev (1923–1997). Istoriki Rossii: poslevoennoe pokolenie. Moscow: AIRO-
HH, 2000. pp. 57–78
70. Titlinov V.P. Pravoslavie na sluzhbe samoderzhavija: iz istorii revoljucionnogo dvizhenija uchashhejsja
molodezhi duhovnyh i srednih uchebnyh zavedenij, 1860–1905 gody [The Orthodoxy service to autocrat monarchy: from the history of revolutionary movement of students of religious and middle-level schools]. Leningrad, 1924.
71. Titlinov V.P. Cerkov' vo vremja revoljucii [The Church during the Revolution]. Sanct-Petersburg, 1924.
72. Tihonov V.V. Istoricheskaja nauka v 1920-e gody: istoriogra cheskie zametki [Historical science in 1920-1929: historiographic notes]. Vestnik Cheljabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2013. No 30 (321). pp. 101-108
73. Tomsinskij S.G. Bor'ba klassov i partij v pervoj Gosudarstvennoj dume [Class ghting and parties in the 1st
Duma]. Rostov on the Done, 1924.
74. Chemerisskij I.A. Istoriogra ja pravomonarhicheskih organizacij (1905–1920) [Historiography of right mo-
narchic organization in 1905-1920]. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v gody burzhuazno-demokraticheskih revoljucij i v period nazrevanija socialisticheskoj revoljucii: materialy konferencii. Ed. by akad. I.I. Minc. Moscow, 1982. S. 66-73
75. Chermenskij E.D. Bor'ba partij i klassov v IV Gosudarstvennoj dume (1912–1917 gg.) [Class ghting and parties in the 4th Duma]. Moscow, 1947.
76. Chermenskij E.D. Burzhuazija i carizm v revoljucii 1905–1907 godov [The bourgeoisie and tsarism in revolu- tion 1905-1907]. Moscow-Leningrad, 1939.
77. 1905 god. Istorija revoljucionnogo dvizhenija v otdel'nyh ocherkah. Istpart CK RKP(b) [History of revolution- ary movement in certain articles]. Ed. by M.N. Pokrovskiy. T. 2. Moscow-Leningrad: GIZ, 1925.
78. Vdovin A.I. Russkij narod i problemy formirovanija sovetskoj istoricheskoj obshhnosti (1930-e gg.). [Electronic resource]. Mode of access: http://www.portal-slovo.ru/history/41178.php
79. Raboty E.D. Chermenskogo o problemah Fevral'skoj revoljucii i ee predposylkah. Mezhdu dvuh revoljucij. 1905–1917 [Electronic resource]. Ezhekvartal'nyj zhurnal istorii i kul'tury Rossii i Vostochnoj Evropy «NESTOR». 2000. No 3. Mode of access: http://secrethistory.su/1324-raboty-ed-chermenskogo-o-problemah-fevralskoy- revolyucii-i-ee-predposylkah.html
80. Shanin T. Uroki istorii i sledujushhaja revoljucija: granicy politicheskogo voobrazhenija [Electronic resource]. Otechestvennye zapiski. 2002. Vyp. No 4–5 (5–6). Mode of access: http://www.strana-oz.ru/2002/4/uroki- istorii-i-sleduyushchaya-revolyuciya-granicy-politicheskogo-voobrazheniya.
Clik here to view.
